In most cases, you should not take insurance when the dealer shows an Ace. Insurance is essentially a side bet that the dealer has a blackjack, and although it offers a 2:1 payout if the dealer does have one, the odds are not in your favor. The probability of the dealer having a blackjack is about 69% when they show an Ace, but the insurance bet has a high house edge of around 7-8%, making it a losing proposition in the long run. The only time it might be worth considering is if you're counting cards and know that the deck is rich in 10-value cards, increasing the chances of the dealer having a blackjack. However, for most players, it's best to avoid taking insurance as it typically results in a negative expected value.